I understand that Johnny Weismuller reigns supreme as the favorite Tarzan among classic movie fans. But personally, I prefer Jock Mahoney, whose intelligent, athletic hero is closer to Edgar Rice Burroughs' literary creation. Mahoney's two movies, Tarzan Goes to India (1962) and Tarzan's Three Challenges (1963), are well-made, colorful efforts that transplant our hero from his African home to India and Thailand. I recently watched the latter film for the first time in several decades.
Woody Strode as Khan. |
A monk has engaged his friend Tarzan to escort Kashi during his perilous trek. However, when the monk is killed, Kashi's guardians question whether Tarzan is who he says he is. Kashi suggests that Tarzan prove his mettle by undergoing tests of wisdom, strength, and skill. (Yes, there are a lot of tests in this movie.) I assume these are the three challenges of the title and they ain't easy! The test of strength requires Tarzan to resist the pull of two buffaloes--going in opposite directions--for five (slow) strokes of a gong.
Do not try this at home! |
Mahoney's Tarzan is a different take on the jungle hero. He's a man dedicated to accomplishing his mission, with no time for romance--despite the presence of Kashi's attractive teacher. He doesn't have a chimpanzee chum and he can't call for elephants to come to his rescue. Best of all, this Tarzan speaks in full sentences and relies on his brains as much as his brawn.
It helps, too, that his adversary is a three-dimensional villain. Yes, Khan may be greedy, but there's nothing wrong with wanting to modernize Tarim. The scenes with his son--who has no desire to be a future king--are particularly well-written. Yet, Khan's viciousness is never in doubt as when he orders the death of an innocent man and tries to kill a defenseless boy.
Mahoney as Yancy Deringer. |
The supporting cast includes the underrated Woody Strode as Khan and Ricky Der as Kashi. Strode, a former decathlete and professional football player, had a long career as a character actor. He appeared in a previous Tarzan movie (as did Mahoney) and later guest-starred on Ron Ely's Tarzan TV series. As for Der, he co-starred opposite Dennis Weaver in the 1964 sitcom Kentucky Jones.
I think Tarzan's Three Challenges is a superior outing for Burrough's famed protagonist. But don't take just my word for it. In his book, Tarzan, Jungle King of Popular Culture, author David Lemme called it "one of the best Tarzan movies."
Mahoney said he never recovered his full stamina. Woody Strode had warned him about swimming the river there.
ReplyDeleteThanks for this. I'm currently watching all of the Weismuller Tarzan movies but will now certainly add the Jock Mahoney films to my list.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was younger, I liked Gordon Scott as Tarzan because of his muscular build.
ReplyDeleteSince then I've seen Herman Brix as the movie serial Tarzan and can understand why Edgar Rice Burroughs chose him as the personification of his most famous creation.
Thanks for the heads up on these two films. I'd never heard of them before.
ReplyDeleteI will say that Jock Mahoney had the best body of any Tarzan in any movie. Sigh.
ReplyDeleteI beg to differ. Mike Henry in a landslide!
DeleteWhen Tarzan Goes To India came out, I saw it at the Circle Theater in Dallas because Jock Mahoney was appearing there. Because there were so many kids there, I had to sit in the balcony. About midway, Jock arrived. They stopped the movie, Jock came out, and I could not hear a word. Right before he left, he raised back his head and gave out the perfect Tarzan call. I loved it. I agree with you, all Tarzan marathons should include Jock Mahoney.
ReplyDeleteWhat a terrific story! I never met him, but he seemed like a really nice guy from I've read.
Deleteand then you find out that he molested his step daughter..
ReplyDeleteYes, that is what Sally Field alleged in her autobiography.
DeleteJock Mahoney remains one of my favorite Tarzans. Sy Weintraub must have liked working with him, as he played 4 other characters in Tarzan stories-- 3 villains and a wildlife preserve ranger.
ReplyDeleteI've read he was in line to replace Lex Barker, but somehow Gordon "muscle beach Tarzan" Scott got it instead. Mahoney was one of the villains in Scott's final Tarzan film (Weintraub's 2nd) and he finally got the role late, and only did 2 films in the process. (It's no wonder I compare him to Timothy Dalton-- heh.)
You know how every time they recast the part, it's like the film series slipped into a different "universe" of sorts, a different version of the character? I've long felt like Ron Ely and Jock Mahoney could be the SAME version, only with Mahoney being an older, TOUGHER Tarzan. Ely got tougher the longer his TV series went on. Both Tarzans are guys you DON'T wanna mess around with!
ditto!
ReplyDelete